sandmansues ([info]sandmansues) wrote,
@ 2004-03-30 18:43:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: contemplative
Current music:Authority Zero--One More Minute

Yet another fake Crossover-Sue!!
I think pretend Crossover-Sues are going to be this week's theme, folks! Today's is a Harry Potter Crossover, and I bet you can't guess what the pairing is! I don't know what scared me more about this author's introduction: the fact that she starts not with her disclaimer or with a short summary but with her own self-proposed


The soundtrack for this particular piece of madness is Sarah Mclachlan's "Fear" and Tori Amos' "Bells for Her" also, U2's "With or Without You." None of the lyrics have anything to do with the lyrics really, but the music itself is what inspired me.

Thank you and enjoy the show.

for the fic, or the fact that she then decides that before getting down to the (thankfully short) story she should throw in a few completely unrelated

I own nothing. All character you recognize belongs either to JK Rowlins or whatever the hell her name is, Or Neil Gaiman.
Quotes of the Day:

Clotho- "What was it, in the end?"

Lachesis- "What it always is. A handful of yarn; a little weaving and stitching; some embroidery perhaps. A few loose ends, but that's only to be expected..."

Clotho and Lachesis, in The Kindly Ones
You people always hold onto old identities, old faces and masks, long after they've served their purpose.

But you've got to learn to throw things away eventually.

Death, in Dream Country
Surfacing.

. Nothing, however, can top her none-too-gracious disclaimer:

"All character you recognize belongs either to JK Rowlins or whatever the hell her name is, Or Neil Gaiman."
Oh, no.
Oh, no no no no no. You did not, just do that, Suethor. Tell me you did not just do that.


STORY OR SERIES TITLE: Before I Wake (gags)
MORTAL AUTHOR: Altagracia (I'll give you *grace*, you little....)
FULL NAME: H... (I can barely say it) Hermione Granger (::dies::)
ENTITY TYPE: human witch
HAIR: not mentioned--pity, I'd love to have seen if it was movie!blonde or book!brown....
EYES: not mentioned--once again I am dissapointed!
DISTINGUISHING FEATURES: none--no brains, no frizzy hair, no books, I keep on seeing her name everywhere, but where did Hermione go?
POSESSIONS: Professor Snape's Heart. (Awww. Isn't that realistic, children?)
PATHETIC ORIGIN: Hogwarts (sigh)
WEAK CONNECTIONS TO CANON: she's stolen the comatose schtick from Preludes and Nocturnes, only with a TWIST!! She must be healed out of her self-induced, not-quite-a-coma by LURVE!! GUESS WHOSE?!?!
SPECIAL ABILITIES: Manages to exist between the realms of ALL of the Endless instead of being stuck in any particular one. Also seems to be able to get away with trying to order Death around and being incredibly rude to Destiny. For some reason both the twins are nice to her and don't mess around with her at all.

NOTES: Rule number one when writing risky pairings in any fandom, is if you want people to take your 'fic seriously, always, always, always have a backstory. I've read cross-generational pairings in the Harry Potter fandom before, but this has to be the first one that just stuck Hermione and Snape together, without any warning or explanation, and expected the audience to overlook the twenty-three year age difference. Meanwhile, Hermione, for the most part, isn't. She seems to know things about the Endless that many people in Rowling's universe wouldn't, which could be explained with the insertion of a few book titles in the girl's memory, but aren't. There's also something intrinsically disingenuous about this Hermione!Sue... instead of making intelligent conversation or attempting to do something constructive in order to help herself and those around her she instead obstinately WANGSTS on about her tragic past in the war against Voldemort and how she had to see Ron and Harry die, boo hoo. She "doesn't want to live anymore", and she's "afraid to love", and only getting pep talks from ALL the Endless, WHILE being pampered bodily by her (former?) Potions Master, AND getting a kiss from Dream at the end can help her see "the truth." What's more, she doesn't even *act* like she's in a coma--she keeps on waking up to look at Snape while he's sleeping, and then going back to sleep of her own volition. That's not a coma that requires you to be carried around and bathed by someone else, that's a nasty case of depression.

SAMPLE THE WORST: Snape's diction (when he's speaking) is in character, but then the prose unexpectedly segues into

"Hermione? "

Him again. Why does he insist on trying to bring me back? I like it here. The darkness is close.

"Wake up."

If death is your friend then you have nothing to fear

"I miss you"

Hold her close and you have no reason to be afraid of anything.

"I love you"

I don't want to be afraid anymore.


SUE RATING FROM ONE TO TEN (ONE BEING OKAY AND TEN BEING AWFUL): 7/10
Her spelling, grammar, and lack of respect for Ms. Rowling who created Snape and Hermione by the way, explain why this Sue-thor has only one review.




(Post a new comment)


[info]bambooshoots
2004-04-01 11:33 am UTC (link)
*blink* The hell? They don't even know J.K. Rowling's name and they're using her characters? *spork*

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]sandmansues
2004-04-01 03:08 pm UTC (link)
I know. I found that bit particularily hard to swallow. I figure this person either only watched the movies and then drenched herself in the Hermione/Snape pairing fandom for some reason, or she *has* read the books but prefers to insult Rowling in order to ingratiate herself with Gaiman fans. Notice how she spelled Neil's name properly.

Now while I've never met Gaiman in person, I have had the pleasure of collecting his works and reading his blog at neilgaiman.com and he really doesn't seem the sort of person who'd be impressed by someone trashing another respected author only to put him higher up on a pedestal. He's really a humble sort of guy.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

off topic
[info]pstindustrialst
2004-04-01 09:29 pm UTC (link)
he's not too bad a person actually.. very quiet and restrained.. i saw him in a bookstore doing a signing/ reading when stardust came out..

he seems pretty cool...

whoever arranged the event though were complete dicks... i overheard one of them saying there should have been a one item limit per person for signage..

>.<

you won't kep fans with that attitude...

but anyhow, neil didn't seem to have a problem with any of it..
he's pretty cool..

*thumbs up*

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]swordmage
2004-04-01 12:31 pm UTC (link)
I do believe that screaming in pain, horror, and agony is the best reply to this.

Oh Foul Sue-Author, thou shalt not touch either Hermione, Snape, or any creation of Gaiman.

(Reply to this)


[info]pstindustrialst
2004-04-01 08:09 pm UTC (link)
there... just... are..... no.... WORDS!!!!

(Reply to this)


[info]hallowd
2004-04-02 01:35 am UTC (link)
Dear, good God. I weep bitter tears at the sight of this travesty. I guess the hope that at least one of my most beloved fandoms would have been free of Sues was in vain from the start...

How dare anyone doe this to The Sandman</i>?</i> I... I just don't know what to say.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]dark_sprout
2004-04-23 07:32 am UTC (link)
I wonder what the Prince of Stories himself makes of all the Mary Sues out there?

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


(Anonymous)
2005-09-16 12:42 am UTC (link)
I've been wondering that myself.
~Weaver

(Reply to this) (Parent)

(Reply from suspended user)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…